Chess Anyone?

Posted: August 18, 2010 by Jeff Craig in Air Force, Boise State, BYU, NCAA Football, Ohio State, TCU, USC, Utah
Tags: , , , , ,

This morning, as I was eating the cream of wheat my wife made me, I flipped on the tube to catch up on the latest sports hype and to my surprise, I see BYU in the headlines. The story went, that they are seriously inquiring about becoming an Independent football team, and joining the WAC for all other sports. My initial reaction was to spew my cream of wheat all over the TV and shout profanities, but an experience or two has taught me better than to spit out my wife’s cooking. So I sat there in awe, dumbstruck if you will. As the day progressed, I pondered this situation, and got on the phone with the most diehard fans I knew to get a solid feel for the BYU fan consensus on this. Let’s review my day.

My boss, a longtime BYU fan had an interesting insight. His view was that we have the BCS right where we want them. As of now there are 6 AQ conferences, however time and time again the MWC has had BCS busters and are soon to break into AQ status. With 8 Bowl games, that would make seven conferences… not something they want to do. By taking BYU out of the Mountain West, the Conference takes a step back, and the BCS can breathe again, here’s the catch, if BYU as an Independent, finishes in the top 8, they get an automatic bid to a BCS game.  His words, “I’ve been waiting 20 years for this moment.”  This could be it.

My brother, an Alumni of BYU, had his short, but sweet comment, “The Ute’s are playing checkers, BYU? We’re playing chess.”  A move to independence is rather chess-like however, if you look at it right. Every big time college football game each season is a conference vs conference game. Look at USC and Notre Dame, or USC and Ohio St. (Notre Dame vs. Anyone used to be huge back in the day). Even MWC fans get very excited for their non-conference play. For example, last year’s win over Oklahoma. I swore that if BYU won one game the whole season, and it were against the Sooners, I would consider it a huge success. What better reward for BYU fans than to stack a whole SEASON with non-conference games? A move to the Pac-10= King me! A move to Independence? That’s checkmate my friends.

I guess when it comes down to it, you have to look at the credibility of the Mountain West. I’ve stood up for them for years stating their strength. With a move to Independence, this will all but crush the MWC ‘s credibility leaving it on the shoulders of TCU and Boise St. I still argue that the additions of Nevada and Fresno St, along with Air Force, and an up and coming Wyoming team, have lots of potential, and I wouldn’t sleep on that conference still. But the idea of independence… that’s just too enticing to pass up.

So, loyal sports fans, I leave it in your hands? I’d like to know if this move was Chess? Or Checkers?

  1. Jeff says:

    By the way, my vote is Chess, in case anyone was still wondering.

  2. Aj the Mighty says:

    Well Jeff, you have to look at it the other way too. I don’t think there is ANY way that the rest of college football would give BYU the same concessions as they do for Notre Dame. Navy and Army are independants too, but have to make the TOP 2 in order to play in a bowl… odds are BYU will have to be somewhere in the middle. And as they don’t have the muscle thye used to (Hall and Dunga are gone you know), it will be a pretty big struggle for them to rank anywhere near that if they only play big name teams. So i say CHECKERS on that one.

    On the flip side, I was talking to a guy here who is more interested in the financial ramifications. He said that Provo has all the capability to force a BIG change in broadcasting it’s own games in HD through BYUTV. So that would mean a LOT more money for the school, and if they do somehow manage to get into a bowl game… they don’t have to split the money with the MWC. So in that aspect: CHESS.

    But no matter the decision, I think we both agree that they need to get consistent and not choke when it may count more than ever now.

  3. Aj the Mighty says:

    Great post by the way Jeffers.

  4. Bleeding RED says:

    So if BYU leaves the MWC, the conference loses it’s credibility, because BYU has been to the BCS three times like TCU and BSU, and has had an undefeated season in the last decade. Oh wait….

  5. Dan Condie says:

    BYU is playing chess/checkers. Utah is playing football.
    This move reminds me of the kid that didn’t get picked for teams on the field or something doesn’t go his way so he grabs the ball and says “fine well now no one can play”
    BYU has single-handedly destroyed the MWC and the WAC in one fell swoop.

  6. Dan Condie says:

    Its possible. I don’t remember

  7. Tanner says:

    I think the bcs has messed up college football and ncaa sports in general. Even though utah can take a pac title in the next few years, they still dont have a guarantee to a championship game. They do get more money either way, but get a harder schedule making it less likely to go undefeated than in the mountain west.

  8. Tanner says:

    In turn, independent byu means they choose most of their schedule plus more exposure, etc. Its unfortunate conferences get Ruined in all this.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s